Saturday, March 27, 2010

India is on a path to become Management Philosophy Superpower

When I was working with TCS as a Management Consultant about 17 years back, all the reference books which we had were written by Western Authors. All our management models revolved around Peter Drucker, Michael Hammer (Reengineering Guru), or Tom Peters. Exceptionally, we would hear name, mainly in the realm of spirituality, like Deepak Chopra. There were hardly any India-Centric management philosophy books written, either by Indian authors or foreign authors. Not any longer. India is on a path to become Management Philosophy Superpower!!!!!!!!


Fast forward 17 years to present 27th March 2010. I went to one-day workshop organized by Department of Philosophy, University of Mumbai and SPM Foundation titled "Chanakya's Management Ideas and Indian Philosophy". What a day it has been!!!!!!!!! First fascinating thing, collaboration between academic institution and management consultancy foundation for the workshop on the philosophy of first management guru Chanakya for the corporate world participants!!! Kudos to vision of Head of Department Dr. Mrs. Shubhada Joshi and SPM Director Radhakrishnan Chanakya Pillai (He has added Chanakya as his second name for brand creation / recall -- he clarified that it is not his father's name!!!!!!!!!!!!).

This carries the utmost significance in an environment where Dr. Joshi had to function within the framework of Government Institution which is not a very conducive environment for such initiatives. Department of Philosophy has come a long way from having a old type-writer which would tear the entire page along with the carbon paper if "O" key is pressed to 11 computers, laser printers, networks, servers, Internet access!!!!!!!!!!!!! Apart from technological transition, what is more important is the sea change in the philosophy of Department of Philosophy itself. Philosophy has always been abstract, obscure subject, typically presumed to be beyond the reach of common people like us and only for the intellectuals with prefix "Dr" before their names!!!!. What the Philosophy department has done is a paradigm shift and brought the philosophy to common (wo)man for improving the quality of life.

On the other side, we have Radhakrishan from SPM foundation. He has identified the power of ancient Indian management philosophy guru Chanakya and significance of his Arthashastra to current corporate world. He, in addition, has understood that partnership with Philosophy Academic Scholars from University of Mumbai would add substantially to his credentials!!!!! That's probably how this joint workshop concept was born. Win-Win for both Philosophy Department and SPM Foundation. Hats off to Academic and corporate world tie-up. India is on a path to become Management Philosophy Superpower!!!!!!!!

As promised, Mala from SPM actually called me on telephone yesterday evening to inform about the venue. Mala, keep up the same responsiveness. You would go places!!!!!!!!! Today, the programme started on time and maintained the schedule to the last minute. In fact, when one of speakers was likely to overshoot his time, a simple note was sent to him to hurry up. When one of the speakers missed covering one important point, again a note was sent to him. Felt really nice with this professionalism. Since organizers were so particular about time, naturally participants also maintained time during breaks. No session commencement was delayed because participants were not in the class.

The first session was by Dr. Mrs. Meenal Katarnikar giving basic introduction of Indian Philosophy and Management, a stage setting one hour session. Clean diction, clear thoughts, confident delivery and outstanding, simple content. My Maharashtrian ego was enhanced for such great opening session from Mahrashtrian Lady!!!!!!! The entire programme was coordinated (Like RJ on a Radio) by Dr. Kamini. In spite of being from the academics, she was absolutely not hesitant in making sales pitch for the department and promoting credentials of the faculties from the department. Madam, keep it up. The academics does need sales person like you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Second session was by Radhakrishnan on Management of Fundamentals in Kautila's Arthashastra. Informal style of presentation; win over the audience with mix of English, Hindi, Sanskrit and even amachi Marathi; He really set the ball rolling. He took the control of the workshop.

Next was Dr. Mrs. Priya Vaidya. What can I say about her? I was spellbound. Calm soothing voice, clarity of thoughts, reflected in the power point presentation. Some slides had probably maximum 9-10 words on it. No titles, no bullets, no graphics nothing. 9-10 words and a lot of empty space on the slide. It reminded me of water colour paintings of one of India's well known painters. He would have maximum white space on the canvass and very few colours. But the painting used to be so eye soothing. Same experience here. Amazing confidence in delivery, yet humbleness to carry and refer to notes from time to time so that no content is missed. Hats off Dr. Mrs. Vaidya!!!!!!! India is on a path to become Management Philosophy Superpower!!!!!!!!

After lunch there was a surprise session by ACP Dhanraj Vanzari. What a person!!!!!! MSc - Organic Chemistry, MA Psychology, Professor before joining police service!!!!!! Number of bravery medals + 2 published poetry books. What a delivery of thoughts!!! An ACP reciting shers, Dnyaneshwar, Tukaram abhangas, quoting Peter Drucker, Stephen Howking!!!!! Dear world, our Indian Police officer is becoming a philosopher and management thinker. India is on a path to become Management Philosophy Superpower!!!!!!!!

Next was hardcore session on Chanakya's 7 pillars of business by Ranjit. Swami-King-CEO, Amatya-Minister-COO, Janapada-Country-Market Place, Durga-Fort-Corporate Head Office, Kosh-Treasury-Finance, Dand-Army-Employees, Mitra-Friend-Stakeholders-Consultant / Advisory Board. And surprise 8th pillart Shatru - that is competition. Amazing co-relation with the today's corporate world. My suggestion to Ranjit would be to create his own presentation rather than depending upon Radhakrishnan's presentation. Ranjit is smart enough to have his own interpretation and delivery of concept. Both Ranjit and Radhakrishnan have potential to be India's budding Management Philosophers. India is on a path to become Management Philosophy Superpower!!!!!!!!

Finally the session by Dr. Mrs. Shubada Joshi. How wisdom, knowledge, confidence can literally transform the environment. Dr. Joshi seems to the classic example. I was thoroughly impressed. By not involving persons like Dr. Joshi in the corporate world as an Advisor, Indian corporate world has missed so much. And this is just one single example. I am sure there are thousands of Dr. Joshis in various Universities, Colleges, Schools who are probably not even aware that they have so much potential to contribute to the corporate world and Indian Management Philosophy. By the way, did you notice something? All the faculties from the Department of Philosophy including the workshop Coordinator were WOMEN!!!!!! See the difference women power is bringing!!!!!!!!!!

India is taking quantum jumps in various fields of knowledge. In fact, knowledge workers helped India where it is today since last 20 years. What we were lacking was India based locally sowed and nurtured Management thinking. I think it is arriving now. Lets keep the momentum going. India is on a path to become Management Philosophy Superpower!!!!!!!!

Milind Kulkarni

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Dear Mr. Kishore Biyani, It happened in Big Bazaar

Dear Mr. Kishore Biyani
kishore.biyani@pantaloon.com.

It could not have happened on a more inappropriate day-- World Consumers' Day - 15th March 2010. Since we have not been to Phoenix Mills for ages together as a family, we decided we would go there yesterday evening looking forward to a lot of window shopping as well discount shopping at Big Bazaar. My wife and son reached from Bandra by bus to Big Bazaar. Since I had meeting, I went directly to Big Bazaar from Churchgate.

We went to deposit our bags at the baggage counter. First touch-point of customer interaction. It was in a shape of Railway ticket counter, same pathetic look and feel and same indifference to customers. We kept on waiting for ages to just handover my bag and take the token. Not that there was a big queue or anything. The baggage counter girl and one of the staff from Big Bazaar were chit-chatting and taking their own sweet time to serve poor customers like us!!!!!!!!! Dear Mr. Biyani, It Happened in Big Bazaar!!!!

Dear Mr. Biyani, I was going to Big Bazaar after reading your book "It Happened in India" with the expectation of watching world class pioneering retail outlet. How do I describe my disappointment? I had read in my MBA school, the quality of any establishment can be verified by looking at the toilets. ST Stand or local station toilets could be better. Unclean smelly toilets, broken taps, empty liquid soap containers. I could not believe that this is Big Bazaar!!!! I was already dreading what am I going to see next.

We started taking rounds of various sections. What I noticed was the clutter and mess everywhere. Atta coming out of packets since packaging was not proper; the packets in the freezer section half opened, some contents removed from the packets!!! And the sad part of everything was the utterly indifferent attitude of the staff to entire affair. We saw atleast 3 instances where staff members were assembling together and chit-chatting. Two staff were actually playing X and 0 (Fully Gola) game. We asked for thick poha standing in front of the shelf containing thin poha. The staff said check in the shelf opposite vegetable section. If thin poha is here, what the hell is thick poha doing in front of vegetable section??!!! No clue. Well, and the beauty of it all, thick poha was not there at all!!!!!!!

My wife was looking at pair of sleepers. She found one sleeper and could not locate another. So she asked the staff for help. Pandya, just see what madam wants. Pandya said, Nitya, search sleeper for madam. Nitya told Satya. Satya told Antya!!!!!!!!!! Finally, my wife asked, what is the problem? Are your duty hours over!!! No, no, Madam. 5 o'clock is our tea break so we are all going for tea. Normally in any customer service area, you take tea / lunch breaks in turns. Not here in Big Bazaar. And the staff was shameless enough to tell this to customer, please wait -- all of us are on tea break!!!!!!!!!!!! And we could not find a supervisory kind of person who seem to be in charge or taking control of anything. It was so unprofessional!!! Can you believe this? Dear Mr. Biyani, It Happened in Big Bazaar!!!!

With our entire trolley filled (we bought trolley load in spite of such pathetic environment), we reached the cash counter. Luckily for us, since it was a weekday, the queue was not long. So after 15-20 minutes, my wife reached to the cash counter clerk. We got stuck at three items. First was set of plastic containers. It did not have bar code on it!!! My wife asked can you send somebody to get another set? Sorry Madam, we do not have anybody to fetch another set. My wife sarcastically asked so do you want me to go there and get another one. Yes Madam. Can you????????? I could not believer my ears. Customer is being asked to get another set because Big Bazaar did not put the bar code!!!!! Fair enough, we did not want to spoil our evening so I kept my mouth shut and anger suppressed. My wife went back to section and got the set with bar code.

Then for Amul cheese and a ladies top, the scanning machine would not read price tags. Madam, this has to be processed manually. Ok go ahead; process manually. No Madam, for these two items, you will have to go to Customer Service Counter. Where is it? It is at the entrance. Being very particular about discounts and freebees, my wife asked, if I process these two items manually, will it get added to my total bill so that I can get free half Kg of Sohanpapadi or not. Sorry Madam, that can not be done. We can not combine manual bill processed at customer service counter with normal bill processed at cash counter!!!!!!!! My blood had already started boiling. Dear Mr. Biyani, It Happened in Big Bazaar!!!!

So now we travel all across the store and reach to entrance to customer service counter. Can you believe what is written there? We regret to inform you that Sohanpapadi is out of stock. Kindly collect it when you visit Big Bazaar next. Who the hell is going to visit Big Bazaar next after such horrific experience?? Oh wait. But just below this flier, there are stacks of Ghasitaram Gulabjam cans. I asked what are these. One blank faced customer service representative told, since sohanpapadi is out of stock, we are giving gulabjam!!! Then what is the meaning of the flier above, I asked? No answer. So finally we had ladies top and cheese processed manually, collected our free gulabjam cans and left Big Bazaar. (By the way, when we came home, we realised that the cheese was not processed at the discount price but at the normal price !!!!!!).

Dear Mr. Biyani, It Happened in Big Bazaar!!!! Happy World Consumers' Day 2010!!!!

We have a long way to go in retail revolution. The sad part is: this is the state of leading retail chain in the country where customers are queuing to enter the store and waiting hours to check out!!!!!!! When, we as an Indian, will get value for our money spent in terms of quality of the product and quality of our shopping experience?????????????


Milind Kulkarni

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Our good old ST is changing

Other day I was traveling from Kolhapur to Pune. It was express bus supposedly stopping only at Satara. I was listening to songs on ishuffle and suddenly after Karad, bus slowed down and turned right into the ST Stand. I was quite sure this was not Satara ST Stand. So I checked which is the town. Name of the town was Atit. Then suddenly it stuck to me. Last time when I had come from Pune to Kolhapur by Karnataka state transport bus, the conductor had told me not to get down at Satara ST Stand for snacks. Instead told me that the bus would stop for 20 minutes at Atit ST Stand!!! That time also I was a bit puzzled.

The stand was very small with just one ST canteen. So I started wondering why every bus is stopping at this ST Stand??? I was quite curious and just went to the controller of the ST stand. Sir, I have one question? I have traveled 2/3 times on this route. Why does every bus stop at this ST stand instead of bigger ST Stands like Satara? The controller stopped whatever he was doing and started talking to me. Can you believe this? I was expecting the guy to just brush me aside. Our good old ST is changing.

Controller explained. Saheb, this town is exactly midway between Kolhapur and Pune. So drivers find it convenient to stop here. But this is official answer. To tell you the truth, conductors and drivers get plenty of food at this ST canteen free. The canteen contractor treats them well. Satara is too big of a ST stand and nobody cares about the ST conductor and driver on that ST Stand. Secondly, since Atit is a small ST stand, if the passenger is missing, the conductor can search him / her easily!!!!! So the local people must be happy that so many buses are stopping in this town. It must be good for their economy. They must be having good business. (My typical MBA thinking.) Our dear controller said, what are you talking Saheb? Do you see any other stall set up near this stand? I looked around and saw none other than canteen. My MBA thinking going for a toss!!! These people get bus every 5 minutes from this ST Stand. But they do not care. ST Mahamandal wanted to build toilets for the passengers and the town opposed vehemently and did not allow the outlet in the town's canal. Finally ST had to dig its own outlet!!!!!! Too much politics. They do not want to take advantage of these so many footprints. (Again MBA thoughts).

Finally I told controller, thank you sir. I will not take more of your time. Please continue your work. Controller said, what are you saying saheb? You are my customer. I have to satisfy your query. It is not obstruction to my work. It is part of my work. If I had told you go to Satara ST stand and ask your queries. What would you have thought? I could not believe my ears!!! I never expected such customer focus from our ST guys. Our good old ST is changing.

Then I got in the bus and bus started moving towards Satara. I was sitting near the Conductor. Man around 55/56 years old. While leaving Kolhapur, he was shouting Pune, Pune till the bus left ST stand. At Kavali naka, bus stop, there also same shouting Pune, Pune. At Atit, same thing. At Satara, he started shouting, people with passes, please do not enter. Some argued. He said, I already have 15 pass holders in the bus. Where will I get money to pay for the toll if I take additional pass holders!!!!!!! Then Pune, Pune shouting continued till he had filled the entire bus.

As we started moving towards Pune and the conductor had settled down after issuing tickets, I approached him. Sir, Can I ask you a question? Do you get incentives based on how many passengers you carry / how much revenue you generate? (Again MBA thinking. Only money can motivate....!!!!) Conductor said, No saheb. Earlier it used to be. But now we do not get any incentives. Then why are you so much bothered about filling the bus? Why are you exerting so much efforts? Saheb, this is my bread and butter. I have to do my job honestly. What the hell am I hearing?? Our good old ST is definitely changing!!!

Then I asked him, why did you refuse the pass-holders? You must be getting credit for pass-holders also. That is true Saheb. But cash is cash. It feels good when you deposit maximum cash at the depot!!!! Let me tell you one thing sir. When bus is fully filled, the load is evenly distributed. The ride is not bumpy. And the bus runs smoothly and it feels good and gives good mileage. So it is good for the ST Mahamandal!!!!!!!!!!! Boy, this is the reason India is shining. Our good old ST is also changing dramatically.