Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Dear Mr. Kishore Biyani, It happened in Big Bazaar

Dear Mr. Kishore Biyani
kishore.biyani@pantaloon.com.

It could not have happened on a more inappropriate day-- World Consumers' Day - 15th March 2010. Since we have not been to Phoenix Mills for ages together as a family, we decided we would go there yesterday evening looking forward to a lot of window shopping as well discount shopping at Big Bazaar. My wife and son reached from Bandra by bus to Big Bazaar. Since I had meeting, I went directly to Big Bazaar from Churchgate.

We went to deposit our bags at the baggage counter. First touch-point of customer interaction. It was in a shape of Railway ticket counter, same pathetic look and feel and same indifference to customers. We kept on waiting for ages to just handover my bag and take the token. Not that there was a big queue or anything. The baggage counter girl and one of the staff from Big Bazaar were chit-chatting and taking their own sweet time to serve poor customers like us!!!!!!!!! Dear Mr. Biyani, It Happened in Big Bazaar!!!!

Dear Mr. Biyani, I was going to Big Bazaar after reading your book "It Happened in India" with the expectation of watching world class pioneering retail outlet. How do I describe my disappointment? I had read in my MBA school, the quality of any establishment can be verified by looking at the toilets. ST Stand or local station toilets could be better. Unclean smelly toilets, broken taps, empty liquid soap containers. I could not believe that this is Big Bazaar!!!! I was already dreading what am I going to see next.

We started taking rounds of various sections. What I noticed was the clutter and mess everywhere. Atta coming out of packets since packaging was not proper; the packets in the freezer section half opened, some contents removed from the packets!!! And the sad part of everything was the utterly indifferent attitude of the staff to entire affair. We saw atleast 3 instances where staff members were assembling together and chit-chatting. Two staff were actually playing X and 0 (Fully Gola) game. We asked for thick poha standing in front of the shelf containing thin poha. The staff said check in the shelf opposite vegetable section. If thin poha is here, what the hell is thick poha doing in front of vegetable section??!!! No clue. Well, and the beauty of it all, thick poha was not there at all!!!!!!!

My wife was looking at pair of sleepers. She found one sleeper and could not locate another. So she asked the staff for help. Pandya, just see what madam wants. Pandya said, Nitya, search sleeper for madam. Nitya told Satya. Satya told Antya!!!!!!!!!! Finally, my wife asked, what is the problem? Are your duty hours over!!! No, no, Madam. 5 o'clock is our tea break so we are all going for tea. Normally in any customer service area, you take tea / lunch breaks in turns. Not here in Big Bazaar. And the staff was shameless enough to tell this to customer, please wait -- all of us are on tea break!!!!!!!!!!!! And we could not find a supervisory kind of person who seem to be in charge or taking control of anything. It was so unprofessional!!! Can you believe this? Dear Mr. Biyani, It Happened in Big Bazaar!!!!

With our entire trolley filled (we bought trolley load in spite of such pathetic environment), we reached the cash counter. Luckily for us, since it was a weekday, the queue was not long. So after 15-20 minutes, my wife reached to the cash counter clerk. We got stuck at three items. First was set of plastic containers. It did not have bar code on it!!! My wife asked can you send somebody to get another set? Sorry Madam, we do not have anybody to fetch another set. My wife sarcastically asked so do you want me to go there and get another one. Yes Madam. Can you????????? I could not believer my ears. Customer is being asked to get another set because Big Bazaar did not put the bar code!!!!! Fair enough, we did not want to spoil our evening so I kept my mouth shut and anger suppressed. My wife went back to section and got the set with bar code.

Then for Amul cheese and a ladies top, the scanning machine would not read price tags. Madam, this has to be processed manually. Ok go ahead; process manually. No Madam, for these two items, you will have to go to Customer Service Counter. Where is it? It is at the entrance. Being very particular about discounts and freebees, my wife asked, if I process these two items manually, will it get added to my total bill so that I can get free half Kg of Sohanpapadi or not. Sorry Madam, that can not be done. We can not combine manual bill processed at customer service counter with normal bill processed at cash counter!!!!!!!! My blood had already started boiling. Dear Mr. Biyani, It Happened in Big Bazaar!!!!

So now we travel all across the store and reach to entrance to customer service counter. Can you believe what is written there? We regret to inform you that Sohanpapadi is out of stock. Kindly collect it when you visit Big Bazaar next. Who the hell is going to visit Big Bazaar next after such horrific experience?? Oh wait. But just below this flier, there are stacks of Ghasitaram Gulabjam cans. I asked what are these. One blank faced customer service representative told, since sohanpapadi is out of stock, we are giving gulabjam!!! Then what is the meaning of the flier above, I asked? No answer. So finally we had ladies top and cheese processed manually, collected our free gulabjam cans and left Big Bazaar. (By the way, when we came home, we realised that the cheese was not processed at the discount price but at the normal price !!!!!!).

Dear Mr. Biyani, It Happened in Big Bazaar!!!! Happy World Consumers' Day 2010!!!!

We have a long way to go in retail revolution. The sad part is: this is the state of leading retail chain in the country where customers are queuing to enter the store and waiting hours to check out!!!!!!! When, we as an Indian, will get value for our money spent in terms of quality of the product and quality of our shopping experience?????????????


Milind Kulkarni

7 comments:

  1. Hi Milind,

    I do not think you are alone in your experience ,
    i have had similar experience in Big Bazaar outlet in Nvai Mumbai.
    If u ask for some item you are pointed to an area and have to go and search for the same .

    My experience elsewhere outside India has consistently been very pleasant you ask for some item in the Hypermarket either Geant or Carrefour and the sales staff walks along with you and ensures you have the item and mind you the sales staff was from my country India .
    so why is that that when it it comes to sales and service back home in an INdian owned company, Indian staff and Indian shopper the experience is pitiful and puts you off.

    still not able to decipher the same .....

    regards
    venkat menon

    ReplyDelete
  2. भयंकर आहे रे हे......!!
    तू लिहिलंस ते बरं केलंस..पण हे वरपर्यंत कसं पोचेल हे पण बघायला हवं.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sadly, I am not astonished to hear on the pathetic retail outlets services back India, as compared to the Kuwait's mega malls services.
    I agree with you 100% and will also share my experience with the Pune Big Bazaar, next time.
    If they too behave the same, ''melach toe...".
    I will not hesitate to share with the media.
    - Raghav C.Sadekar

    ReplyDelete
  4. Its the same everywhere, in any mall, boss. Whether Big Bazaar or Chor , sorry More. The best we can do is to go the neighbourhood grocer. They have improved their service because of this competition.Even if you save some in a mall, which I am not sure, given the tendency to buy unnecessary things in unnecessary quantities.You end up wasting a lot of time, peace of mind and getting stuck in a jam.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dear Milind,
    While I am not very shocked to hear the inferior service quality given in indian retail business, which is really growing at a fast pace. It is the classical problem of too much in too little time, without proper set of policies and procedures which are transformed in the practices.

    It is the socio environment in India, where LET IT GO attitude really promotes such callous attitude of employees. We should actually show and demonstrate the people from Philipines, Burma etc..who have better customer oriented attitude.

    I would say the problem is in attitude of employees and not the organisation. Later when such attitudes go beyond the boundries of the country, it becomes nation's attitude. In service industry the bigger super / Hyper markets have stopped the recruitments from India. The origination of such attitude is with retail chains in India. Let Mr. Biyani and his team inform their employee association about the fact and the perception of indian work force in this industry internationally.

    Anand
    anand796@yahoo.co.in

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sairam SubramanianMarch 19, 2010 at 5:12 AM

    Hi Milind

    I think you went through a horrible experience at the Big Bazaar - I have also had the occasion to visit couple of them both in Mumbai as well as Chennai and have realised that the employees are generally not traianed adequately regarding Customer Service - their idea is to be there and just inform Customers regarding availability or not of a particular item and just indicating area of the store where it could be available - They are generally not sure - One of the problems that I realise is that theese stores are not adequately staffed as compared to the no of customers who walk in - so there is a gap there also

    Here in Muscat, the customer service at the big hypermarkets - Lulu, carrefour, Safeer are quite good
    I hope that thigs would change for the better in India shortly

    Sairam Subramanian

    ReplyDelete
  7. मूर्ख आणि मंद पणाचा कळस आहे , management नी यावर खुपच गंभीरतेने विचार केला पाहिजे ... खरा म्हणजे हि mentality बदली गेली पाहिजे...

    ReplyDelete